Gareth@toastedmallow

reviews

65 reviews

Slapshot: Rebound cover

Slapshot: Rebound · 2024 · Nov 17, 2026

6

hockey where the puck actually behaves like a puck, and the fun is in the scrum more than the scoring

0 0

Def Jam: Fight for NY cover

Def Jam: Fight for NY · 2004 · Nov 14, 2026

6.5

took a few fights before the controls started clicking, but once they did it was a lot of fun. mixing styles to build my own fighter kept me tinkering longer than i expected. the fights themselves are a bit repetitive, so it's more of a 'one more match' kind of game than a grab-you-by-the-collar one.

0 0

Plants vs. Zombies cover

Plants vs. Zombies · 2009 · Nov 14, 2026

7

sneaky addictive. kept saying one more level and then it was 2am. some stages got a little samey near the end but it's hard to stay mad at something this charming.

0 0

Dustforce cover

Dustforce · 2012 · Nov 14, 2026

6.5

Simple premise, and it's a joy to zip around cleaning up messes with a bit of style. The controls felt tight and satisfying once I got the rhythm down. It doesn't go very deep, but I had a good time with it in short bursts, which is honestly how I'd want to play it.

0 0

Castle Crashers Remastered cover

Castle Crashers Remastered · 2015 · Nov 12, 2026

7

a blast with friends, a bit lonely solo. the smashing is great and the art is gorgeous, but the grind wore thin for me by the back half. still a good time to crash some castles.

0 0

Teamfight Tactics cover

Teamfight Tactics · 2019 · Nov 10, 2026

6.5

kept coming back to it in short bursts, which is about the right amount for a game like this. the rounds are easy to fall into and hard to walk away from, and i never quite felt in control of the outcome, which was half the fun. not a game that clicked with me all the way, but i understand the pull.

0 0

Resident Evil 4 cover

Resident Evil 4 · 2011 · Nov 10, 2026

8

the shooting felt good enough that i didn't mind the slow parts, and i liked that it kept pulling me forward instead of letting me sit around. it's a solid trip through a game i've heard about forever. not perfect for me, but i'd happily go back in for another round.

0 0

Resident Evil 3: Nemesis cover

Resident Evil 3: Nemesis · 1999 · Nov 9, 2026

7

the tension is great, the way it keeps you on edge with that relentless pursuer is still effective. the fixed camera angles and tank controls are a bit of a chore though, and it can feel stiff compared to what I'd like now. I did enjoy the ride, especially the final stretch where the pressure really builds. the puzzles are simple, and I didn't mind that. it's more about managing your supplies and staying calm than anything clever. some of the pacing dragged for me in the middle. all in all a solid, memorable horror experience with a few rough edges that show its age. I'd still recommend it to anyone who wants a classic spooky night in.

0 0

Dishonored 2 cover

Dishonored 2 · 2016 · Nov 9, 2026

6

lots of freedom to play it your way, and i appreciated that. but i kept bouncing off the stealth stuff and the pacing felt uneven. smart game, just not always fun to sit with.

0 0

Disney's Donald Duck: Goin' Quackers cover

Disney's Donald Duck: Goin' Quackers · 2000 · Nov 8, 2026

6

ok this one was kinda fun in a silly way. never felt like it wanted to be more than it was, which i respect. got a bit fiddly toward the end but the wacky energy carried it.

0 0

Rivals of Aether II cover

Rivals of Aether II · 2024 · Nov 8, 2026

5.5

fun in short bursts and the platform fighting feels good when it's clicking, but I bounced off the longer sessions. finished it, enjoyed it more than I thought I would.

0 0

Apex Legends cover

Apex Legends · 2019 · Nov 6, 2026

8.5

didn't expect to get this invested in a free game, but the squad play kept pulling me back. the characters feel fun to switch between and the moment-to-moment shooting is tight. only knock is that a few rounds got chaotic in ways that felt more random than earned.

0 0

Call of Cthulhu cover

Call of Cthulhu · 2018 · Nov 4, 2026

5

the atmosphere is thick and the dread builds nicely, which i appreciated. i just got worn down by the slower stretches and the fiddly bits that pulled me out of the mood. the mystery kept me going, but it didn't fully earn my patience. wanted it to grab me harder than it did.

0 0

Limbo cover

Limbo · 2010 · Nov 4, 2026

7

Quiet, moody, and tense from start to finish. I kept wanting to know where the kid was headed next, and the puzzles felt good to figure out. It doesn't say much out loud, which I appreciated. Took me a while to see the end, but it stuck with me once I did.

0 0

FIFA Soccer 08 cover

FIFA Soccer 08 · 2007 · Nov 3, 2026

6

it's a football game that plays like a football game. nothing fancy, the ball goes where you aim it most days, and that's fine by me.

0 0

Heroes of Might and Magic III: The Restoration of Erathia cover

Heroes of Might and Magic III: The Restoration of Erathia · 1999 · Nov 2, 2026

5.5

mixed feelings, a lot of turns, a lot of clicking, and it's still the kind of thing i'd pick up again on a slow weekend.

0 0

Stories Untold cover

Stories Untold · 2017 · Nov 1, 2026

4.5

a quiet little collection that went down easy. the puzzles were more about thinking than fumbling, which i liked. it didn't hit me hard, but it kept me curious until the end. felt more like a pleasant evening than a big event.

0 0

Psychonauts cover

Psychonauts · 2005 · Nov 1, 2026

6

weirdly charming and I wanted to love it more than I did. the mind levels have a lot of personality and some of them are really clever. but the platforming got fiddly for me and I stopped caring about the bigger picture by the end. decent, just not my favorite.

0 0

Fable: The Lost Chapters cover

Fable: The Lost Chapters · 2005 · Nov 1, 2026

6.5

charming in spots, but it wandered more than I wanted and the rpg side never clicked for me.

0 0

Frog Fractions cover

Frog Fractions · 2012 · Nov 1, 2026

6.5

Went in expecting a silly little browser toy and came out with a weird grin and a lot of questions. The frog stuff is simple enough to get going, and spending points on upgrades gave me a reason to keep poking at it. It really is a spoof of those educational games, and the joke landed for me more than I expected. Not every bit felt tight, and some of it wore thin once I'd seen where it was going, but it was short, strange, and honestly kind of charming. Worth a few minutes if you're in the mood for something that doesn't take itself seriously at all.

0 0